Got this for Christmas and read it on Christmas day. It was fun, and the art was great. I was just a little sad that, in a boy/girl sibling pair, it's the girl who gets lured into danger and has to be rescued. I wanted a page where she's brandishing a sword and fighting off a zombie. But overall, fun.
books 2014: Throne of Isis, by Judith Tarr
Dec. 8th, 2014 10:40 amI adore Judith Tarr (I don't know why no one else seems to read her!) but this one wasn't a standout for me, possibly because I knew going in exactly how it would end, as it's Cleopatra after all. Dione isn't a fantastic heroine/narrator for me - she was okay, but not as good as Meriamon in Lord of the Two Lands. And Tarr couldn't pull off the sexual awakening plotline as adeptly in this book as in that one, considering that this heroine is a mature woman with two children. I just wanted them to get to it already. The unexpected character death at the end threw me, though. Why did Tarr have to do that? (Only because it's exactly what that character would have done but still!!) Anyway, it was a book that bothered me, and in that sense Tarr was successful, I suppose, but this isn't one I'll reread.
I've been looking forward to this a while. Only three stars because at this point this series has gone on so long that I can't remember who everybody is anymore and sometimes there are plot points around events from previous books that I don't remember the details of. Overall I liked the ending (while I agree with the reviewers who say that the character death was broadcast early and was too easily gotten out of, I was still glad at the way things turned out).
Can't remember when I read this, so I'm just going to say "Octoberish".
Can't remember when I read this, so I'm just going to say "Octoberish".
I'd read these before in comic book format. This is the volume where Buffy time-travels to the future, and this is where things start to go a little south for me. ( Read more... )